Jacob Corral Mendoza
ASU Student Journalist

Angelo Pugnetti goes from fiery competitor to guiding hand for Higley tennis

November 14, 2026 by Jacob Corral Mendoza, Arizona State University


Higley's boy's freshman tennis team (Courtesy Angelo Pugnetti)

Jacob Corral Mendoza is an ASU Cronkite School of Journalism student assigned to cover Higley High School  for AZPreps365.com 

Before Angelo Pugnetti started coaching young tennis players through the ups and downs of competition, he first had to get a handle on his own emotions. In high school, his fiery on-court temper led campus security guards to nickname him “McEnroe,” after John McEnroe, the famously fiery tennis champion.

These days, as the coach of Higley High School’s freshman boys tennis team, Pugnetti uses those early lessons to help first-time players get their bearings. He focuses on making the court welcoming, then figures out how to push each player just enough without spoiling the fun.

“When I was a young athlete, I was stubborn and hot-headed,” Pugnetti said.

It took time for him to actually enjoy the game. That memory is what now helps him connect with players whose emotions sometimes get in the way.

For freshman Winston Merz, that understanding mattered during a match against Brophy when his serves were causing problems.

Pugnetti said he adjusts his approach based on how each player responds. For Merz, the advice that helped was about where to put his attention rather than how to fix his technique.​

“Between sets, Coach kept telling me to forget about the mistakes and focus on the next point,” Merz recalled. “That helped me stay in the match and not get too frustrated.”

Joining the team felt less intimidating, Merz remembers, because Pugnetti welcomed newcomers, asked about their background, and helped them improve step by step.

Coaching runs in Pugnetti’s family. His dad coached several sports, and his brother now coaches minor league baseball. For Pugnetti, there’s nothing better than seeing someone else succeed because of his help, even more than his own wins on the court.

“My number one goal is to give these kids a high school experience they’ll actually remember,” Pugnetti said.

Pugnetti took over Higley’s boys tennis program in the summer of 2024 after eight years leading the Casteel girls program, which he started from scratch. He also coached at Sossaman Middle School.

With beginners, he first wants them to have fun on the court with their teammates. Once he sees they’re hooked, he ramps up the challenge, changing his approach depending on what each player needs.

Last season, a freshman kept hitting balls into the net, so Pugnetti told him to aim 20 feet deep if that’s what it took to get the ball over. Eventually, the player adjusted and kept getting better.

Merz has noticed that mix of encouragement and high expectations at every practice and meet, and the team feeds off Pugnetti’s energy.

Pugnetti believes having friendly competition with teammates helps beginners develop a lasting love for tennis. Once that interest takes hold, he finds it much easier to push them to work harder and improve.

“Coach makes tennis fun because he's always energetic and joking around with us,” Merz said. “But at the same time, he wants us to get better and compete.”

Off the court, Pugnetti likes antique shopping and playing poker. He and his wife, McKenna, often escape to Pine for a little peace and quiet.

The couple met through friends and hit it off talking baseball. McKenna has noticed her husband’s competitive streak shows up in everything from board games to trivia nights, and that he’s always eager to share random bits of knowledge.

“He has an impressive amount of knowledge about the most random things, and he loves any opportunity to share it,” she said.

At home, McKenna often hears stories about students falling in love with tennis and the little tweaks her husband makes in his coaching to help them get there.

“I love hearing how excited he gets when something finally clicks for one of his players,” she said.

For Pugnetti, the real goal goes beyond tennis. He hopes his players leave with close friendships and remember him as someone they could always turn to for help.

Already, Merz sees a link between his coach’s own past and the patience he shows to players now.

“He’s told us about going through some of the same stuff as a kid, so it feels like he really gets what we’re dealing with,” Merz said.